My form insurance company over compensated me $66,667.83 over days gone by 4 years. Why do I hold to recompense it posterior?

I called the insurance company 4 years ago and told them they be paying me to much. I called three times & spoke next to three different people. They adjectives said I was getting the right amount. I received a phone up two days ago from the Insurance company. They want the over payment pay for in one month. Plus they hold on to on sending me checks...I dont understand why I enjoy to pay them final when its their fault and their still sending checks to me.
Do I really enjoy to pay them posterior?? I dont have that nature of money laying around surrounded by my check book.
I would love some answers to this Mess I'm in.
Thanks within advance P-Sue
Answers:
stop cashing surrounded by the checks.

doesn't matter who's bad habit it is, if it's not money your entitled to, you don't get to maintain it.

Other Answers:
I would get an attorney if I be you before you respond.
I dont know... But I gain ask my friends about this. :-)
that sucks they should only shove it because it was near fault
Contact a advocate, I hope you can document your conversations.If so they may be willing to negotiate, especially if they are still overpaying you. Big insurance companies are infamous for making mistakes and then asking you to fix them.
If your'e on LTD you should telephone the ins. co and ask them about a lump sum settlement...they will want to balance the settlement by the overpayment amount, but it is a viable option depending on your age and specifics of your suitcase. If you refuse to clear, all they can do is drop u to the minimum benefit.
First, since you realize that you were unloading an overpayment and you opted to currency the checks regardless, you will be help responsible for paying off the overages.

Second, contact an attorney who can negotiate a settlement rate for you. Even if you're able to document that you spoke next to someone at the company and they assured you the amount was correct, by your cashing the checks, you signified you agreed the amount be correct.

Good luck.