Anyone know of a company that does not market insurance but order them (i.e. existence and Health)?
There are companies that grade the financial strength of insurers. Two prominent ones are AM Best and Standard & Poors.
I think you might be looking for a broader answer though. It is a notably subjective question that depends on what factors are considered. You could be asking more or less best coverage, best service, best claims treatment, best rates, best location, best educational info ... you get the notion. I am not aware of any company that does that. It would be a huge task to do right.
As a broker I try to do that work for my clients. You should find a broker licensed in your nouns and talk to that broker about your requests.
I suppose the next question would be - how to find a upright broker? That's also very subjective!
Answers: Try Consumer Reports at http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/money...